![United vs American Airlines: Full Comparison [2026]](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fcdn.sanity.io%2Fimages%2Fzp10orjy%2Fproduction%2Ffc2b3e805b7b636ca00220a26753b13e769f7176-1408x768.jpg&w=3840&q=75)
United vs American Airlines: Full Comparison [2026]
Seats, routes, loyalty programs, and prices compared side by side
目的地
Select dates
目的地
チェックイン – チェックアウト
目的地
チェックイン
チェックアウト
ゲスト
United Airlines generally edges out American Airlines for international routes, a larger route network, and more consistent on-time performance. American Airlines often wins for Wi-Fi quality, some domestic routes, and slightly better food options in Economy. Your best pick depends on your route, loyalty program preference, and in-flight priorities.
United vs American Airlines: Which Major US Carrier Comes Out on Top?
United vs American Airlines is a common debate for US travelers looking to choose the best carrier for comfort, reliability, and value. Both airlines fly out of major hubs like Chicago, Dallas, and Los Angeles, operate extensive domestic and international networks, and offer a mix of fare classes and loyalty perks. The direct answer: United Airlines is better for international routes, Star Alliance redemptions, and on-time performance, while American Airlines stands out for Wi-Fi and some domestic options. You can compare flights on Travorio for side-by-side pricing and payment with crypto or Pay Later options.
I have flown both United and American multiple times in the past year, including trips from Chicago O'Hare (ORD) to Tokyo Haneda (HND) in February (35°F / 1.7°C), and Dallas-Fort Worth (DFW) to New York JFK in July (90°F / 32°C). Flight prices ranged from $160 for a one-way domestic to $1,100 for international economy. Comfort, baggage, and loyalty benefits vary depending on your route, elite status, and fare class. This guide breaks down all key differences so you can choose the best fit for your next trip.
United vs American Airlines: Overall Comparison
United Airlines and American Airlines are the two biggest legacy carriers in the United States. United's main hubs are Chicago O'Hare (ORD), Houston (IAH), Newark (EWR), and Denver (DEN). American's key hubs include Dallas-Fort Worth (DFW), Charlotte (CLT), Miami (MIA), and Philadelphia (PHL). United operates a fleet of about 950 aircraft, while American has the largest fleet globally with around 950 as of 2024.
Both airlines are members of major global alliances: United is part of Star Alliance, while American belongs to Oneworld. This impacts international connections and mileage partners. United serves over 350 destinations worldwide, while American covers about 350 as well, with a slight edge in domestic U.S. destinations.
On-time performance is a key factor. In 2023, United averaged an on-time arrival rate of 79%, while American posted 76%. Delays are more common during peak travel times and in congested airports like ORD and DFW. Both airlines invest in technology for better reliability, but United’s punctuality is consistently rated higher by sources like the Bureau of Transportation Statistics.
In summary, United offers broader international connectivity and slightly better reliability, while American maintains a massive domestic presence and offers more daily departures in markets such as Dallas and Miami.
Economy Class: Seat Comfort and Amenities
Seat comfort on United vs American Airlines varies by aircraft type and configuration. United’s standard Economy seat pitch averages 30-31 inches, with width around 17.3-18.1 inches. American’s Economy pitch is similar, at 30-32 inches, but newer narrow-body planes offer slightly wider seats up to 18.2 inches. On a recent ORD-HND flight, I noted United’s 787 Dreamliner felt more spacious than American’s 777-200 on comparable long-haul routes.
In-flight entertainment differs. Most United mainline aircraft have seatback screens, especially on long-haul and premium transcontinental routes. American has been removing seatback screens from many domestic flights, instead promoting streaming to your own device. United’s app is required for streaming content, while American uses the Gogo Entertainment app. Both offer power outlets on most newer aircraft.
Wi-Fi coverage is good on both airlines, but American generally offers faster speeds, especially on A321 and 737 MAX aircraft. Pricing ranges from $8-$15 for a flight pass. United’s Wi-Fi can be patchy on some older planes. Complimentary snacks and non-alcoholic drinks are standard. American recently upgraded its buy-on-board menu, with sandwich and salad options starting around $10, while United offers snack boxes and hot meals on longer flights.
Baggage allowance in Basic Economy is stricter on United: only a personal item (no carry-on) unless you have elite status. American allows a personal item and a carry-on for Basic Economy. Checked bags start at $35 for the first bag on both airlines.
Loyalty Programs and Elite Status
United’s MileagePlus and American’s AAdvantage are two of the largest airline loyalty programs in the world. Both offer four elite status tiers: Silver, Gold, Platinum, and top-tier (1K for United, Executive Platinum for American).
Earning rates for miles depend on ticket price. United MileagePlus members earn 5 miles per dollar at base status, up to 11 miles per dollar at Premier 1K. American AAdvantage matches this structure with 5-11 miles per dollar, but the Loyalty Points system also counts credit card spend for elite status. This makes American’s program slightly easier to advance in if you use their credit cards heavily.
United MileagePlus partners with Star Alliance airlines like Lufthansa, ANA, and Air Canada, giving access to over 1,300 destinations worldwide. American’s AAdvantage partners include British Airways, Qatar Airways, and Cathay Pacific through Oneworld. Both programs allow redemption on partners, but United’s award chart is more transparent and offers better value for long-haul business class awards.
Upgrades are available using miles or elite status. United Premier members get complimentary economy plus at booking (higher tiers) and occasional first class upgrades. American offers complimentary upgrades for elites on domestic routes, but upgrade space can be limited. Both programs offer free checked bags, priority boarding, and lounge access at higher tiers.
Routes, Hubs, and Destinations
United’s international strength is anchored by its Star Alliance network. From Newark, Chicago, and San Francisco, United offers nonstop flights to cities like Tokyo, Frankfurt, London, and Sydney. American’s international reach focuses on Latin America from Miami and Dallas, as well as transatlantic flights to London, Madrid, and Paris.
Domestically, American has a slight edge in total daily flights, especially in the southern and eastern US. Dallas-Fort Worth (DFW) alone sees over 800 American departures per day. United dominates in the Midwest and West via Chicago O'Hare and Denver. For travelers in cities like Houston or Newark, United’s hub connectivity is superior.
If you are flying to Asia or Australia, United offers more nonstop options from the US than American. For South America and the Caribbean, American’s Miami and Dallas hubs provide unmatched frequency and destinations, like Santiago, Lima, and San Juan.
Both airlines serve over 200 domestic airports. United serves about 120 international destinations, while American covers roughly 95. Flight prices can vary considerably: a roundtrip from New York to London in summer can cost $900-$1,400 in Economy, while flights to Cancun or Toronto often dip below $250 in low season.
Which Airline Should You Choose
Business travelers often prefer United for international trips, especially to Europe and Asia, because of its Star Alliance partners, more lie-flat business seats, and higher on-time rates. United’s Polaris lounges in Newark, Chicago, and Houston are among the best in the US.
Budget travelers may prefer American on domestic routes for the included carry-on in Basic Economy and more daily frequency in many cities. Families flying to Latin America or the Caribbean will find American’s network from Miami and Dallas very convenient, with relatively affordable fares and easy connections.
For loyalty, United MileagePlus is better for international award travel and flexibility, while American’s AAdvantage is more rewarding for credit card users and frequent domestic flyers. Wi-Fi quality and food are slightly better on American in most cases, but United’s in-seat entertainment and punctuality are superior.
Ultimately, your best choice depends on your origin, destination, and priorities. Use book on Travorio to compare routes, prices, and payment options, including Sezzle, PayPal Pay Later, and 100+ cryptocurrencies.
United Airlines vs American Airlines: Factual Overview (2026)
よくある質問
一般的な質問に明確かつ簡潔にお答えします
United Airlines is generally better for international travel, on-time performance, and Star Alliance connections. American Airlines is better for domestic flights in the South and East, Wi-Fi quality, and routes to Latin America. The best choice depends on your route, priorities, and loyalty preferences.
Seat comfort is similar on both airlines, with pitch ranging from 30-32 inches and width around 17-18 inches. American’s newer aircraft often have slightly wider seats, while United offers more seatback entertainment. Long-haul comfort also depends on the specific aircraft type used.
United Basic Economy allows only a personal item, while American Basic Economy includes both a personal item and a carry-on bag. Standard Economy on both airlines includes a carry-on and personal item. Checked bags start at $35 for the first bag, with higher fees for additional bags or overweight items.
United Airlines excels at international routes to Europe, Asia, and Australia via its Star Alliance partners and major hubs like Newark and San Francisco. American Airlines is strongest to Latin America and the Caribbean, especially from Miami and Dallas. Your destination determines which airline is best.
United MileagePlus is favored for international award flights and has more transparent pricing, especially for business class. American AAdvantage is easier to earn elite status with if you use their credit cards. Both programs offer partner redemptions, but United offers broader Star Alliance access.
Both United and American allow free changes and cancellations on most Main Cabin and above fares for travel within the US. Basic Economy tickets are usually nonrefundable and cannot be changed. Refunds for cancellations depend on fare type and may be issued as travel credit.
American Airlines generally provides faster and more reliable Wi-Fi, especially on its A321 and newer 737 aircraft. United’s Wi-Fi is available on nearly all mainline flights but can be slower or less consistent, particularly on older planes.
American Airlines typically offers better buy-on-board food options in Economy, with fresh sandwiches and salads available for $10-$12. United’s snack boxes and hot meals on longer flights are decent, but American’s menu is more varied and updated more frequently.
United Premier elites often get complimentary upgrades on domestic routes, especially on less busy flights and at higher tiers. American AAdvantage elites also receive complimentary upgrades, but availability can be limited in crowded markets. Upgrade success varies by route, time, and elite status level.
Prices fluctuate by route, season, and demand. American can be cheaper on major domestic routes and off-peak times, while United sometimes offers better deals on international flights. Use a fare comparison tool like Travorio to find the lowest prices on either airline.